The tough job of saving their jobs

Cleveland Browns helmet logo


This season is not over by a long shot.

The AFC and NFC divisional playoffs are this weekend, the conference championship games are next weekend and then two weeks after that comes something called the Super Bowl.

So, then, there is a lot of football — the best part of the season, really — left to be played.

But already the clock is ticking on the Browns’ top two football men, General Manager Andrew Berry and head coach Kevin Stefanski, for next season.

Can they save their jobs?

In a general sense, I don’t see how that happens. They’ve been here together for five seasons and have just two playoff appearances and but one postseason win to show for it. The latter of the two playoffs trips came in 2023 and was a one-and-done as the then upstart Houston Texans pounded them in a 45-14 win. That type of play continued going into this season as, despite expectations that they would go back to the postseason and advance further, becoming a legitimate contender to go to the Super Bowl, things just hit rock-bottom with a 3-14 finish.

There was also this little boo-boo — just a miscalculation, as the Browns would like you to believe — involving quarterback Deshaun Watson. In reality, the trade to get him, giving the Texans three first-round picks in the NFL Draft and then signing him to a fully-guaranteed $230 million contract, only to find out he can’t play and excels sokely in getting hurt and doing some distasteful off-the-field things, all right is the worst deal in Browns history and probably also NFL history. It makes the previous bust record-holder, the trade of Paul Warfield to the Miami Dolphins for the No. 3 overall draft pick in 1970, which was used to take Mike Phipps, look like a veritable steal.

Most teams would have canned Berry and Stefanski as soon as the 2024 regular season ended with a 25–point loss in Baltimore, if not sooner, but Browns owner Jimmy Haslam decided to keep them both.

For how long, though?

And with what expectations?

Would Haslam endure another 3-14 finish in 2025, only this time with a much younger roster and the hope provided by a talented rookie quarterback plucked with the Browns’ No. 2 overall draft choice this spring?

Again, who knows?

But this much we do know: Haslam wants to get some public money to help him build that new domed stadium in Brook Park, but his team having finished 11 games under .500 in just a 17-game season, and the fact his competitiors in Cleveland, the record-setting 35-5 Cavaliers and the Guardians, coming off an appearance in the American League Championship Series, are stealing all the limelight, is not good PR for that effort.

At what point, then, does Haslam cut his losses and pull the plug on the Berry-Stefanski team, even if he wants to keep his front office intact, and not blow things up again, in the name of continuity?

That remains to be seen.

Winning fixes everything — it covers up the problems — but it’s hard — if not downright impossible — to envision the Browns getting many wins with the current roster. And there’s way too much to do in one offseason to build a new roster capable of contending.

Yes, it will be a busy time in the coming months, with many more questions than answers, especially when it comes to Kevin Stefanski and Andrew Berry.

And those two men, and their boss, Jimmy Haslam, have only themselves to blame for this Lake Erie-sized mess.

Steve King



Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail