Originally published: Wednesday, August 19 (PM)
Cleveland Browns cornerback Justin Gilbert has had a rough start to his NFL career — no doubt about it. Struggles in coverage, lapses in technique, and questions about his commitment have all raised red flags. It’s fair to critique his performance, even harshly at times.
But it’s also fair to ask for a little decency.
Gilbert Deserves Accountability — But Not Public Humiliation
Let’s be clear: I’m not suggesting Gilbert is the next Clarence Scott or Frank Minnifield. He might not even make it to next season if things don’t change dramatically. But the way some members of the Buffalo Bills media treated him during Monday’s joint practice with the Browns was flat-out disgraceful.
According to eyewitness accounts, a few Buffalo reporters openly laughed at Gilbert while he struggled on the field — some even shared snide remarks on social media. That’s not coverage. That’s cruelty.
Pro Tip: Looking to better understand cornerback play? Check out Take Your Eye Off the Ball 2.0 — a must-read for football fans who want to grasp the finer points of the game.
The Role of the Sports Media: Inform, Don’t Ridicule
Having spent nearly four decades in this business, I’ve learned that being a member of the press comes with responsibilities — chief among them is professionalism. Whether you’re at the stadium, the locker room, or on Twitter, you’re representing your publication.
When you act like a drunken frat bro cracking wise at someone’s expense, it doesn’t just reflect poorly on you. It tarnishes your outlet, your profession, and the trust fans place in you.
Media Access Is a Privilege, Not a Punchline
Reporters are given access most fans would dream of — practices, interviews, behind-the-scenes intel. The job is to report, not roast. Assess players through the lens of football knowledge, not personal pettiness. If you want to play stand-up comic, get a mic and hit an open-mic night — not the sideline of an NFL camp.
Want to upgrade your sideline reporting game? Here’s the gear I recommend for professionals:
Zoom H4n Pro Recorder – Ideal for post-practice interviews
Rode SmartLav+ Lavalier Mic – Clear audio for your mobile setup
The Sportswriter’s Notebook – Perfect for jotting insights before they hit Twitter
A Final Word to the Mockers: Grow Up
This business can be tough. NFL athletes like Justin Gilbert live under constant scrutiny — and yes, performance matters. But ridicule has no place in professional journalism.
So, to those in Buffalo who treated Gilbert like a punchline: act like you’ve been there before. Because right now, you’re making the rest of us look bad.
You’re better than that.
Or at least, I hope you are.
Steve King
READ NEXT: Cleveland Browns Father’s Day Gift Guide
