Originally published August 29, 2015 — updated for relevance in 2025.
In the summer of 2015, the Cleveland Browns found themselves caught in a familiar struggle: the search for quarterback stability. Veteran Josh McCown, signed in free agency to be nothing more than a stopgap, suddenly found himself cast in a starring role — not by design, but by default.
Check out the Browns Store on Amazon
With backup quarterback Johnny Manziel sidelined due to shoulder soreness — officially labeled a two-week absence but unofficially considered longer — McCown stood alone as the only healthy and dependable quarterback on the Browns roster heading into the all-important third preseason game against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
From Bridge to Backbone
McCown was expected to “hold the seat warm” until Manziel or another quarterback of the future was ready. But as Manziel’s availability and long-term outlook became murkier, McCown’s role evolved. At age 36, he wasn’t just a mentor — he was the only option. That night in Tampa, McCown essentially became the Browns’ starting pitcher in a must-win game: no relievers, no plan B.
Cleveland had outbid the Buffalo Bills to sign McCown, hoping his experience would stabilize the locker room and help guide a young offense. But dysfunction at the front office level — including then-GM Ray Farmer’s infamous Textgate scandal — continued to disrupt the organization’s structure and vision.
Pettine Under Pressure
Head coach Mike Pettine found himself caught in the chaos. While not directly responsible for the front office issues, he was left to clean up the mess. With just over two weeks until the regular-season opener, Pettine’s task was clear: rally a banged-up, uncertain roster and prepare them for Week 1.
This is where McCown’s leadership truly mattered. He wasn’t just the quarterback — he was a field general, a locker room presence, and a bridge to a better version of the Browns, if such a version could emerge from the dysfunction.
Injuries Compound the Chaos
Adding to the turmoil, the Browns roster was riddled with soft-tissue injuries, particularly hamstrings, causing key players to miss time throughout camp. Among them were wide receiver Terrelle Pryor and rookie running back Duke Johnson — two potential offensive X-factors the team desperately needed to evaluate.
Both were expected to play in the Tampa Bay preseason matchup, offering fans and coaches their first glimpse at what they could bring to an offense sorely lacking in big-play potential.
Why This Game Mattered
The preseason dress rehearsal wasn’t just another tune-up. For McCown, it was a chance to solidify his grip on the starting job. For Pryor — still transitioning from quarterback to receiver — it was a chance to prove he belonged on the 53-man roster. And for Johnson, it was an opportunity to demonstrate why he was drafted to energize the backfield.
If nothing else, the Browns needed this game to show signs of life — a little rhythm on offense, some leadership under center, and hope that their playmakers could, in fact, make plays.
Why It Still Matters Today
Looking back, the 2015 Browns season — and Josh McCown’s unexpected role — marked another chapter in the team’s long-running quarterback carousel. The events of that August night in Tampa underscore a larger truth that still resonates in Cleveland: until you fix the quarterback position and front office culture, everything else is just noise.
- NFL RedZone Subscription Gift Card
- Wilson “The Duke” Official NFL Football
- NFL Training Camp Chairs & Canopies
- Fantasy Football Draft Boards & Kits
- NFL Legends: 100 Years of Football
Note: We may be compensated for purchases made through links on this website at no additional cost to you. Thank You!
READ NEXT: Cleveland Browns Fan Favorites
