Updated Aug. 8, 2025 originally published Wednesday, Sept. 2, 2015 (PM) – It appeared to be a game of similar teams, similar head coaches and similar quarterbacks when the expansion Browns visited the Philadelphia Eagles in the preseason finale 16 years ago today, on Sept. 2, 1999.
The re-born Browns were starting over again after a three-year absence from the field with an offensive-minded coach in Chris Palmer and young stud quarterback in rookie Tim Couch, taken at No. 1 overall in the 1999 NFL Draft.
After being just 3-13 and 6-9-1 the previous two seasons, the Eagles were being re-born, too, just not quite as dramatically. Coach Andy Reid, also with an extensive offensive background, was going with his own rookie hopeful at quarterback, Donovan McNabb, selected right behind Couch at No. 2.
Both teams knew it would take a while to get things going again, but their sights were set high, nonetheless.
The Browns faltered down the stretch and lost the game 30-17, finishing their first preseason of the expansion era with a 2-3 record.
It didn’t take long to dash either team’s expectations. The Browns finished a franchise-worst 2-14, while the Eagles were but 5-11.
However, things changed dramatically the following season – at least for one club. Philadelphia flipped its record in 2000 and went 11-5 to make the playoffs for the first time since 1996. Reid and McNabb were off and running.
But the Browns, with Couch missing much of the year with a broken thumb, were only 3-13, causing Palmer to get fired after compiling a 5-27 record.
And in subsequent seasons as Reid and the McNabb were making the Eagles one of the top teams in the NFL, Couch faltered and then before too long was out of the league as the Browns were through one head coach – and, after Couch’s departure – one quarterback after another. Since then, they’ve made the playoffs just once and have had only two winning records.
But no one could have envisioned all of that on that night 16 years ago when what appeared to be two clones played at Veterans Stadium.
Related: Cleveland Browns Fan Favorites
Official Cleveland Browns Apparel on Amazon
Cleveland Browns Men’s Nike Game Jersey
Nothing says “team spirit” like a high-quality replica jersey. Nike’s officially licensed Browns jerseys come in all sizes and feature the latest players, from Deshaun Watson to Myles Garrett. Perfect for game day or casual wear.
- Breathable material
- Authentic team colors and logos
- Available in youth and adult sizes
NOTE: We are compensated by purchases made through Amazon links on this website at no additional cost to you
Updated 2025: Top 5 Tim Couch Highlights
-
1999 Hail Mary vs. Saints
Couch launched a miraculous last-second touchdown to Kevin Johnson, securing the Browns their first win since their reactivation—an iconic moment in franchise history. He’s the only QB in NFL history with two 50+ yard walk-off TDs as time expired. -
2002 Hail Mary vs. Jaguars
In another breathtaking finish, Couch delivered a game-winning “Hail Mary” pass as the clock hit zero, marking the second such play of his career. -
Late-game heroics in the 2002 season
That year, Couch spearheaded multiple game-winning drives—including a 31–28 OT win vs. Tennessee, a clutch two-point conversion against the Jets, another final-minute touchdown vs. the Ravens, and the aforementioned Jaguars miracle. -
December 30, 2001 – High-powered showdown vs. Titans
Couch put on an offensive clinic: 20-of-27, 336 yards, 3 TDs, with a 74% completion rate and a 137.3 passer rating in a thrilling 41–38 win. -
College legacy—Seven TDs vs. Indiana (1998)
Before entering the NFL, Couch had a legendary college performance, tossing seven touchdowns in a single game—one of 26 school records he held—solidifying his “air raid” quarterback legacy.
Bonus: A Video Recap
This YouTube compilation captures many of Couch’s standout moments—from his dramatic Hail Marys to other flashes of brilliance—package in one highlight reel.
